While the rude, belligerent and impatient debt collectors who sometimes harass Americans about money owed are a royal pain, at least they don’t have a habit of threatening to rip your children from your care and toss them into a foster home.
Apparently, this habit is only reserved for the unrepentant officials of the Wyoming Valley West School District in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania.
These now-notorious officials sent a letter to some parents earlier this month warning them that failure to pay off their children’s school lunch bills could literally cost them their children.
“At this time, multiple letters have been sent home with your child and no payments have been made to their account,” the letter reads. “Your child has been sent to school every day without money and without a breakfast and/or lunch.”
“This is a failure to provide your child with proper nutrition and you can be sent to Dependency Court for neglecting your child’s right to food. If you are taken to Dependency Court, the result may be your child being removed from your home and placed in foster care.”
Controversy and outrage over a letter sent to parents by Wyoming Valley West School District regarding delinquent lunch payments. The District says their children could be taken away and placed in Foster care. It’s a story you don’t want to miss on Eyewitness News. @wbrewyou pic.twitter.com/QSuyLFFJAm
— Andy Mehalshick (@AndyMehalshick) July 18, 2019
Around 1,000 local families owe a combined $22,000 in lunch debt. According to school officials who spoke with The Washington Post, only families that owed more than $10 received the letter.
While it’s unclear how the letter went viral, it sparked widespread backlash, to the point that even Sen. Robert P. Casey Jr. remarked on it.
“No child should have to imagine the horror of being ripped away from their parents because their family is struggling economically. These letters were callous and should never have happened,” he tweeted Friday, a day after the story broke.
No child should have to imagine the horror of being ripped away from their parents because their family is struggling economically. These letters were callous and should never have happened. https://t.co/TVbsh2XIRy
— Senator Bob Casey (@SenBobCasey) July 19, 2019
Moving forward, the School District has an obligation to find an appropriate way to collect these funds, instead of using threats
— Senator Bob Casey (@SenBobCasey) July 19, 2019
County officials also opined on the matter.
“I found it very disturbing. Upsetting. It’s a total misrepresentation, a gross misrepresentation of what our agency does,” Luzerne County Children and Youth Services executive director Joanne Van Saun said to local station WBRE.
She added that the county has never and would never “remove children from families for unpaid bills.”
In a twist of irony, late Thursday county manager David Pedri sent his own somewhat threatening letter to Wyoming Valley West School District officials.
“This is a gross misrepresentation as to what we do. What you are really doing is weaponizing the good things we are doing in Luzerne County. I’m asking the school district to retract the letter,” he wrote.
He reportedly got his wish.
“Future collection letters will not mention anything about foster care, and the district will send letters apologizing to parents who received letters with the foster-care warning, school board Vice President David Usavage said,” local newspaper The Morning Call reported Friday morning.
But there are a couple of notable caveats.
For one, neither the school district’s federal programs director, Joseph Muth, who was the one who signed the letter, nor the district’s school solicitor, Charles Coslett, who reportedly wrote the letter, seem to think they did anything wrong.
“Hopefully, that gets their attention — certainly did, didn’t it?” Coslett said in a joint interview with WBRE. “I mean, if you think about it, you’re here this morning because some parent’s crying foul over he or she doesn’t want to pay a debt. A debt attributable to feeding their kid. How shameful.”
Listen to their stunning interview below:
Muth was slightly less acerbic.
“It might be a bit heavy for some people in interpretation. … But to the point, the school district wants to take their kids away from them. No one wants to take their kids away from them but we were not getting any responses,” he said.
At least they’re honest …
Second, while the school district plans to adjust its strategy, it reportedly still intends to stick to the whole threatening parents with punitive consequences modus operandi.
“The Wyoming Valley West School District says it will send out a second, softer letter to parents who are delinquent in paying their children’s lunch bills,” WBRE reported. “We’re told parents face legal action from the district, including a complaint in district court and having liens filed against their personal property.”
Not everybody feels bad for the parents, though. Some have echoed Coslett’s sentiment that the parents should be more financially responsible.
School bills can be paid ahead of time or parents can pack lunches for their kids. Whatever happened to P, B & J, or Baloney & Cheese sandwiches? That’s what my generation ate & we survived just fine! We also had almost no problem with obese children. pic.twitter.com/fd3viV63JH
— Kathy Barrett Baker (@kbsquared1961) July 20, 2019
Pay up I’m tired of paying your Bill’s in my taxes
— Marsha Muir (@MarshaMuir4) July 19, 2019
Parents aren’t responsible for feeding their children? Is this how it starts? Let the Nanny state pay??———-School district warns parents: Pay lunch bill or kids may go into foster carehttps://t.co/8pR1thgWqM
— Janice Donalson (@janice_donalson) July 20, 2019
While I do not agree with the foster care warning, it’s amazing that everyone’s comments are about how the food should be FREE. There is no parental responsibility. Nanny state mentality.
WVW kids face foster care over lunch billshttps://t.co/FFr06grXo0
— American Lee 🇺🇸 (@scroarty) July 18, 2019
You also have to realize any school board has to be responsible financially. Since these parents were not responding to the school in regards to their misguided ways. What other recourse do they have or is it free lunch for everyone. I think not!
— Richard Ellis (@rickellis306) July 20, 2019
That would definitely get my attention. Although I don’t agree with threatening to remove children from their parents, it’s ridiculous to owe that much lunch money. If you can’t afford it fill out the free lunch application!
— Tara M. Carroll 🇱🇷 (@taracarroll3) July 20, 2019
Latest posts by Vivek Saxena (see all)
- Turley says Dems have led vicious smear campaign, threats pouring in since testifying against impeachment - December 6, 2019
- McCarthy fires back at Pelosi: ‘This is the day Alexander Hamilton warned would come’ - December 5, 2019
- Pelosi SNAPS when James Rosen asks if she ‘hates’ Trump: ‘Don’t mess with me!’ - December 5, 2019