Who will beat the nation’s ‘most vulnerable Democrat’?

Congressman Patrick Murphy, who recently eked out a victory over former Congressman Allen West in District 18, has now been labeled  the “most vulnerable Democrat.”

Sabato’s Crystal Ball, the product of highly respected University of Virginia Center for Politics Director Larry J. Sabato, said just that on Feb. 7. The Crystal Ball has been a leader in accurately predicting elections across the country.

One way to determine vulnerability of Democrats in Congress is to look at districts where Mitt Romney won yet the Republican congressional candidate lost. An analysis of Congressional District 18 shows that Romney won the district, and the numbers show how vulnerable Murphy may be in 2014.

Romney Obama West Murphy
Palm Beach 71,066 65,699 68,348 68,158
Martin 48,183 30,107 43,333 32,532
St. Lucie 56,202 65,869 52,672 65,567
Total Votes 175,451 161,675 164,353 166,257
Percentage Total of 2-way race 52% 48% 49.7% 50.3%


The numbers clearly show this is a swing district.

Conventional wisdom suggests that in 2014, the Republican turnout will be greater than Democratic turnout. This is a reliable pattern in Florida: Democrats can’t seem to turn out their voters in non-presidential years, and President Obama seems to attract a high number of voters who only vote when he’s on the ballot. We’ve already seen what can happen when Obama voters stay home. Just look at 2010.

The question is whether Republican turnout will mirror 2010, when tea party enthusiasm catapulted Republicans to their largest victory since 1946 and the majority in the U.S. House. Many political prognosticators see 2010 as a possible high-water mark for Republicans and doubt it can be repeated, but shortly after the 2008 presidential election, many would have doubted Republicans would win back the House only two years later.

Patrick Murphy photo from TC Palm

photo credit: Deborah Silver, Treasure Coast Newspapers (via TC Palm)

West has said he won’t be running in 2014, so who will step up to the plate? Two former Republican congressional contenders may be interested. State Rep. Gayle Harrell competed in the 2008 Republican primary for the old Congressional District 16, which covered a large portion of the current District 18. While Harrell lost that primary to Congressman Tom Rooney, she was re-elected to the Florida House in 2010 after sitting out one term, pursuant to Florida’s constitutionally mandated term limits.

State Sen. Joe Negron also competed in the old Congressional District 16, in 2006 (a Democratic year), replacing Mark Foley after his abrupt resignation. Foley’s name stayed on the ballot, but all his votes were awarded to Negron. Even with such a liability, Negron came within just 1.8 points of winning the old Congressional District 16. Negron is unlikely to run, though, since he’s the presumptive Florida Senate president in 2016. MaryLynn Magar recently won a state House seat in the area, and of course, Pat Rooney may want to join his brother, Congressman Tom Rooney, in D.C. Other Republican officeholders in the area or even a well-funded political newcomer would stand a good chance of making Murphy a one-termer.

Debbie Wasserman Schultz and the Democratic National Committee clearly targeted West, directing tons of party money to help Murphy. Democrats relished the chance of defeating such a staunch conservative and nationally known Republican rock star like West. The Palm Beach Post recently reported that the Democratic super PAC known as the House Majority PAC spent $2.4 million ripping West, who raised $19.4 in traditional campaign contributions while Murphy raised $4.7 million. Super PACs supplemented those totals by spending $3.5 million to help Murphy and $3 million to help West. It’s highly likely that the DNC and Democratic PACs will assist Murphy again in 2014, but without Obama on the ballot, it remains to be seen whether Murphy will be able to energize Democratic voters to win another term in a less-friendly cycle.


Allen West calls media out for ‘softball’ treatment of Obama

Democratic PAC’s ‘hit list’ for 2014 GOP congressional seats

Allen West to NRA group: ‘An armed man is a citizen; a disarmed man is a subject’

Richard DeNapoli

Richard DeNapoli is an attorney and the former chairman of the Broward County Republican Party. Often referred to as a “numbers guy,” he offers analysis of political statistics to BizPAC.

Latest posts by Richard DeNapoli (see all)


  • KB Cook

    Humpty Dumpty sat on the wall – Humpty Dumpty will take the great fall

  • Murphy's oil

    We've got to put up someone against this pencil pushing punk. He probably thinks he's da man for beating West but me thinks that was a fluke. Lets get behind someone and take this seat back.

  • Take back Cd18

    Let's face it….Murphy got lucky. The Ds wanted to take down West so bad that they poured money into Murphy's race. I doubt they will do the same to protect Murphy now that he's in. West was an awesome Congressman, but Murphy was able to nationalize the campaign since West was a national star…and DWS wanted West out of Congress. While I'd love a West-Murphy rematch, we've got to find someone capable to start early and start raising money. The small donor Dems won't be there for Murphy this time, since they really didn't even know who he was – he was just the anti-West.

  • Allenhip

    Allen West wasn’t the problem it was the Republican Platform.

    The question you need to ask is why so many Republicans lost here in Florida?

    The next question is why are Democrats courting moderate Republicans to join the Democratic Party?

    Could it be that they are going to widen the voter base to win elections?

    There was a side-by-side study done that DID NOT change one word of either the Republican or Democratic Platforms.


    Example of one of the 30 platforms issues: Most senior voters did not want to privatize Social Security.

  • Cassandra

    Anyone at all has an excellent chance of beating Murphy as long as the Supervisor of Elections in Port St Lucie is not running the tabulations on election night.

  • http://None Richard DeNapoli

    Just wanted to thank BizPAC for asking me to write, and for many of the comments and well-wishes I've received via email. Many have asked who I think could win. I think Congressman West would stand a great chance of beating Murphy in 2014. West has 100% name ID and as I pointed out above, the district leans Republican and it's doubtful that the Democrats can turn out the Obama voters without Obama on the ballot. Republicans have turned out in higher numbers relative to Democrats in off-years for many cycles, and its likely to continue in 2014. West has proven his fundraising ability, and I'd wager he would far outraise Murphy in a rematch. But Congressman West has said he wouldn't be running. We're still pretty far out from 2014, but I'm sure the Republicans will field a great candidate against Murphy.

  • kateinmacclenny

    Hi, Richard, with 144% of voters in Lucie CO per SOE for Murphy, what should we do? WHY won't GOP fight this illegal or skewed results throughout America?? like Lucie CO, OH, PA, VA, etc. We work hard for candidates and GOP/RNC takes money, doesn't sue and allows illegal or erroneous results to stand. The thing with Foley drove us nuts. Foley resigning drove us nuts. Why do GOP candidates look like cowards? We'd love West to wipe the floor with Murphy and friends.

  • http://None Richard DeNapoli

    Hi Kate @9:31 … The 141% number was because of a two page ballot. Also, some voters didn't vote both pages. See an article here about this situation: http://m.tcpalm.com/news/2012/nov/12/st-lucies-to

  • http://www.allenwestrepublic.com Tanya

    Well, he won't last long and someone with integrity and strength is needed. I pray someone will announce soon as campaign funds will be needed desperately to fight off the democratic machine. We witnessed that first hand this last election.

  • Cassandra

    True the vote is suing the Supervisor of Elections in Port St Lucie. If you want to do something meaningful- send them a contribution.

Related Posts